1 Corinthians 4

Scripture quotations on this page are from the World English Bible (public domain), shown in quotation marks; all commentary is written by Scripture Trove. Source: 1 Corinthians 4 · Commentary

Contextual Placement

Chapter 4 is Paul's closing argument in his discussion of church unity (Block One: 1:1–4:21 now reaches its conclusion here). The preceding three chapters tore down the idol of human wisdom, established an epistemology grounded in the Spirit's revelation, and exposed the spiritual immaturity behind the factions. In chapter 4 Paul pulls the focus back onto himself: What is an apostle, really? Not the celebrity you idolize, but Christ's "bottom-deck oarsman," a steward of God's mysteries, whose one performance review is faithfulness and whose only judge is the Lord himself. Then Paul's tone pivots sharply into the most biting sarcasm in the entire letter: "You are already full! You have already begun to reign!" — setting the Corinthians' self-inflation alongside the apostles' actual circumstances in a brutal contrast. Finally he pulls back into a father's tenderness: I am not writing this to shame you, but because you are my spiritual children.

Narrative Unit

This chapter concludes Block One, "Church Unity" (1:1–4:21). Chapters 1–3 argued at the theoretical level why factions are absurd; chapter 4 makes the practical close: the apostle's true portrait (4:1–13) → a father's appeal (4:14–17) → a warning about the coming visit (4:18–21). Beginning with chapter 5, Paul turns to specific ethical issues (sexual morality, lawsuits, marriage, and more).

Structural Overview

The chapter has four movements, tracing an arc from positioning to sarcasm to tenderness to warning:

Structural Relationships

The four sections form an emotional arc of "statement → conviction → contrast → homecoming." The first two sections calmly state the apostle's identity and the limits of who may judge; the third section suddenly heats up, using scorching irony and a description of suffering to hold the Corinthians' pride up against the apostles' blood and tears; the fourth section just as suddenly softens, as Paul shifts from sarcasm to tenderness: I am your father, and I write these things because I love you. The whole chapter breaks off on a choice between "the rod or gentleness."

Core Message

Apostles are not celebrities but stewards, and faithfulness is the only standard. What do you have that you did not receive freely? Since everything is grace, what grounds do you have for boasting? Paul sets the apostles' suffering (hunger, nakedness, beatings, being treated like garbage) side by side with the Corinthians' self-satisfaction (full, rich, reigning), and this mirror exposes a piercing truth: the real shape of following Christ is not glamour and prestige but becoming "the scum of the world, the refuse of all things" for Christ's sake.

Key Verses

4:2 "Here, moreover, it is required of stewards, that they be found faithful."

1 Corinthians 4:2(World English Bible)

4:7 "For who makes you different? And what do you have that you didn’t receive? But if you did receive it, why do you boast as if you had not received it?"

1 Corinthians 4:7(World English Bible)

4:20 "For God’s Kingdom is not in word, but in power."

1 Corinthians 4:20(World English Bible)

Pastoral Heart

Dear brothers and sisters,

"What do you have that you did not receive?" If this single sentence truly sinks into your heart, it can heal a great many things.

It can heal your pride, because not one of your gifts, your achievements, or your spiritual experiences was earned by your own effort. It can heal your envy, because what others possess was not earned by them either; God simply gave different gifts. It can heal your anxiety, because you do not need to "manufacture" anything to prove your worth; you only need to faithfully manage what God has already given you.

Paul does something very brave in this chapter: he lays the apostles' real circumstances open for the Corinthians to see — hunger, beatings, being treated like garbage. He does not gloss over the hardship, and he does not say "follow Christ and everything will go smoothly." He lives out an undignified faithfulness: not the faithfulness of a celebrity pastor adored by crowds, but the faithfulness of someone trampled underfoot who still blesses the one trampling him.

But what moves me most is the turning point at 4:14: "I don't write these things to shame you." After all the severity and sarcasm, what Paul carries in his heart is a father's tenderness. He gets angry not because he hates you but because he loves you.

What has God done for you? He has given you everything freely: spiritual gifts, salvation, brothers and sisters, even all things themselves (3:21–23). You do not need to compare yourself with anyone, because the gift you received is one of a kind. And God's evaluation of you is not "Are you more successful than others?" There is only one standard: Are you faithful? On that day when "each one receives commendation from God," what he looks at is not how many great things you did but whether you were faithful to what was entrusted to you.

Reflection Questions

  1. "Who makes you different? What do you have that you did not receive?" If you truly believed this sentence, how would your tendency to compare yourself with the brothers and sisters around you change?

  2. Paul describes the apostles' real circumstances as "hunger, beatings, being treated like garbage." What does your mental picture of "successful ministry" look like? How does Paul's self-portrait challenge that picture?

  3. Paul finally asks the Corinthians, "Do you want me to come with a rod, or with love and a gentle spirit?" If the Lord Jesus asked you the same question today, does your life right now need discipline or comfort?

4:1–5 Stewards and Judgment: Only the Lord Has the Right to Judge

4:1 "So let a man think of us as Christ’s servants, and stewards of God’s mysteries."

1 Corinthians 4:1(World English Bible)

Two identity markers. ὑπηρέτης (hypēretēs, "servant") originally named the oarsman on the lowest deck of a trireme — a three-tiered warship — the lowest-ranking laborer, entirely under the captain's command. Paul uses this word to define the apostle: we are not the captain; we are the bottom-deck rowers. οἰκονόμος (oikonomos, "steward") was the servant in an ancient wealthy household who managed the estate — not his own wealth, but the master's.

"Stewards of God's mysteries": μυστηρίων θεοῦ (mystēriōn theou) echoes 2:7, God's "hidden wisdom." The apostle's task is not to invent truth but to faithfully safeguard and distribute what the master has already entrusted to them. This fundamentally tears down the basis for "idolizing preachers": a steward does not deserve to be idolized, only the master does.

4:2 "Here, moreover, it is required of stewards, that they be found faithful."

1 Corinthians 4:2(World English Bible)

The evaluation criterion is radically simple: not whether you are eloquent, not whether the church is large, not whether you are popular, but whether you are faithful. πιστός (pistos, "faithful, reliable") is the one quality a steward must prove.

This sentence is freeing for every preacher and ministry worker: God does not require you to be successful; he requires you to be faithful. You cannot control whether the church grows (that is God's work: 3:6), and you cannot control what others think of you, but you can control whether you are faithful to what has been entrusted to you.

4:3 "But with me it is a very small thing that I should be judged by you, or by man’s judgment. Yes, I don’t judge my own self."

1 Corinthians 4:3(World English Bible)

ἀνακρίνω (anakrinō, "to examine, to judge") is the same verb that appeared in 2:14–15 ("the spiritual person discerns all things"). Now Paul says: your assessment of me, any human court's assessment of me, counts as next to nothing in my eyes. Even my own assessment of myself does not constitute the verdict.

"I don't even judge my own self": this does not mean Paul never reflects on himself; it means he does not treat his own self-evaluation as the final ruling. Human self-knowledge is limited. Feeling that you have done nothing wrong does not mean you actually have not.

4:4 "For I know nothing against myself. Yet I am not justified by this, but he who judges me is the Lord."

1 Corinthians 4:4(World English Bible)

σύνοιδα (synoida, "to be conscious of, to know together"): "My conscience does not accuse me of anything." But Paul immediately adds a qualifier: a clear conscience ≠ innocence. The authority to judge is not in my hands, not in yours, but in the Lord's.

This is a powerful corrective to the "judgment culture" common in many churches. We are far too quick to pass ultimate verdicts on preachers: "he is very spiritual" or "there's something wrong with him." Paul says: stop. This authority does not belong to you.

4:5 "Therefore judge nothing before the time, until the Lord comes, who will both bring to light the hidden things of darkness, and reveal the counsels of the hearts. Then each man will get his praise from God."

1 Corinthians 4:5(World English Bible)

Paul is not saying never judge; he is saying not now (πρὸ καιροῦ, pro kairou, "before the proper time"). Wait until the Lord comes, and then settle it. At that time the Lord will do two things: bring to light what is hidden in darkness, and reveal the motives of every heart. People can only see the surface; the Lord sees the motivation.

"Then each one receives commendation from God": the final commendation comes not from a congregational vote but from God. This gives immense comfort to every faithful servant who labors unseen.

4:6–7 Do Not Be Puffed Up: What Do You Have That You Did Not Receive?

4:6 "Now these things, brothers, I have in a figure transferred to myself and Apollos for your sakes, that in us you might learn not to think beyond the things which are written, that none of you be puffed up against one another."

1 Corinthians 4:6(World English Bible)

"Transferred to myself and Apollos": μετασχηματίζω (metaschēmatizō, "to change the outward form, to apply figuratively"). Paul acknowledges that in chapters 1–3 he used "Paul and Apollos" as his examples as a rhetorical strategy. The actual divisions probably involved more names, but he used himself and Apollos as the illustration, both to avoid the awkwardness of naming names directly and to show that "even apostles should not be idolized."

"Not to think beyond the things which are written": the original phrasing. This is a boundary Paul draws for the Corinthians: do not evaluate a preacher beyond the framework Scripture gives. How does Scripture define a preacher? Servant, steward, worker — not idol, not celebrity.

4:7 "For who makes you different? And what do you have that you didn’t receive? But if you did receive it, why do you boast as if you had not received it?"

1 Corinthians 4:7(World English Bible)

Three questions in a row, each more piercing than the last:

First question: who made you different from everyone else? Answer: God. Second question: what do you have that you did not receive freely (ἔλαβες, elabes, "received")? Answer: nothing. Third question: since it was all received, on what grounds do you boast (καυχᾶσαι, kauchasai)? Answer: you have no standing to.

These three questions are the logical core of the entire "unity" argument, and the most thoroughgoing response to all pride. Your eloquence, your learning, your gifts, your spiritual life — which of them was not given by God? Since they are all gifts, what reason do you have to look down on someone who received a different gift?

This passage speaks just as directly to the culture of comparison among believers everywhere: comparing who is more spiritual, whose church is bigger, whose ministry is more fruitful. Paul says: these are all gifts, not achievements.

4:8–13 The Apostles' Reality: You Reign as Kings; We Face Death

4:8 "You are already filled. You have already become rich. You have come to reign without us. Yes, and I wish that you did reign, that we also might reign with you."

1 Corinthians 4:8(World English Bible)

Three "already" declarations (ἤδη, ēdē) come down like a barrage: already full, already rich, already reigning. This is the most caustic sarcasm in the whole letter. The Corinthians feel they have "arrived": full, rich, reigning, as though God's kingdom had already been fully realized.

Paul's sarcasm carries real theological depth: Christians will indeed reign with Christ one day (Revelation 20:6), but that is "future," not "now." The Corinthians are committing a kind of "over-realized eschatology": treating a future promise as a possession already in hand.

"I wish that you did reign": Paul suddenly slips in a flash of genuine feeling — I really wish you were right, so that I could share in the blessing with you! But what is the reality? See the next verse.

4:9 "For, I think that God has displayed us, the apostles, last of all, like men sentenced to death. For we are made a spectacle to the world, both to angels and men."

1 Corinthians 4:9(World English Bible)

θέατρον (theatron, "theater, spectacle"): Paul invokes the image of the Roman arena — condemned prisoners brought out last to be put to death before the watching crowd. The apostles are not the stars on the stage; they are the prisoners in the arena waiting to die, with the whole universe (humans and angels) watching this "performance."

This image stands in brutal contrast to the picture of the Corinthians "reigning" in 4:8: you sit in the stands imagining you are kings, while we bleed down on the floor.

4:10 "We are fools for Christ’s sake, but you are wise in Christ. We are weak, but you are strong. You have honor, but we have dishonor."

1 Corinthians 4:10(World English Bible)

Three pairs of contrasts, each one ironic: foolish, wise; weak, strong; despised, honored. Paul applies the logic of the cross from 1:25 ("the foolishness of God is wiser than men") to the apostles: those who truly follow the cross look foolish, weak, and despised, while those who consider themselves wise, strong, and honored may be the farthest from the cross.

4:11-13 "Even to this present hour we hunger, thirst, are naked, are beaten, and have no certain dwelling place. We toil, working with our own hands. When people curse us, we bless. Being persecuted, we endure. Being defamed, we entreat. We are made as the filth of the world, the dirt wiped off by all, even until now."

1 Corinthians 4:11-13(World English Bible)

This is Paul's "apostolic hardship catalogue," a kind of list that recurs in 2 Corinthians 4:8–9, 6:4–10, and 11:23–28. He shifts from sarcasm into a raw description of reality. This is not a rhetorical technique; it is his actual life.

"Hunger, thirst, naked, beaten": every verb is in the present tense. "Even to this present hour" he is still going through it. This is not a past-tense memory but his ongoing daily life.

"When people curse us, we bless": this directly echoes Jesus' teaching in the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5:44, "Bless those who curse you"). The apostles do not merely preach Christ's teaching; they have lived it out.

"The filth of the world, the refuse of all things": περικάθαρμα (perikatharma) originally named the material used in purification rituals to wipe away contamination, a rag used once and thrown away. περίψημα (peripsēma) is "the scraping wiped off a dish." Paul chose the most degrading words available: in the world's eyes, the apostles are garbage.

This passage is the most severe judgment on today's "success"-driven church culture. If your standard for "ministry success" is comfort, respectability, and the esteem of others, Paul would say: that is not what an apostle looks like. An apostle looks like hunger, beatings, and being treated as garbage, all while blessing the very people who curse him.

4:14–21 A Father's Heart: Not Shame but Warning

4:14 "I don’t write these things to shame you, but to admonish you as my beloved children."

1 Corinthians 4:14(World English Bible)

Paul's tone makes a sharp turn here, from sarcasm and the description of suffering to sudden warmth: "I am not writing these things to humiliate you, but to admonish you as my beloved children."

νουθετέω (noutheteō, "to correct, to warn") comes not from hostility but from love. The biting irony of 4:8–13 is now to be read as a father's discipline of his children: the words are harsh because he loves them.

4:15 "For though you have ten thousand tutors in Christ, you don’t have many fathers. For in Christ Jesus, I became your father through the Good News."

1 Corinthians 4:15(World English Bible)

παιδαγωγός (paidagōgos, "tutor, guardian-slave") is not a "teacher" but the slave in the ancient world responsible for escorting a child to and from school. Such a guardian disciplines you but does not love you. Paul says: the Corinthian church has ten thousand such tutors, but only one father gave you birth, and that is me. "In Christ Jesus, through the gospel, I gave you birth."

This is not prideful boasting but the establishment of his authority to speak: a passing tutor may criticize you, but only the father who gave you birth has the right to discipline you. Paul speaks so severely to the Corinthians precisely because he holds this "father" relationship with them.

4:16 "I beg you therefore, be imitators of me."

1 Corinthians 4:16(World English Bible)

"Be imitators of me": read right after the hardship catalogue of 4:11–13, this is especially powerful. Paul is not saying "imitate my preaching technique" or "imitate my theological depth," but "imitate the way I suffer for Christ." Imitate how he blesses when cursed, endures when persecuted, and does not give up serving even when treated as garbage.

4:17 "Because of this I have sent Timothy to you, who is my beloved and faithful child in the Lord, who will remind you of my ways which are in Christ, even as I teach everywhere in every assembly."

1 Corinthians 4:17(World English Bible)

Paul sends Timothy ahead. On the one hand he is delivering a "living letter," so the Corinthians can see how Paul's teaching takes shape in a real person; on the other hand it is a way to test the waters, gauging their attitude before Paul himself arrives. Timothy is called "my beloved and faithful child in the Lord," echoing 4:2's "a steward must be faithful": Timothy is the living example of exactly the faithful steward Paul has described.

4:18-19 "Now some are puffed up, as though I were not coming to you. But I will come to you shortly, if the Lord is willing. And I will know, not the word of those who are puffed up, but the power."

1 Corinthians 4:18-19(World English Bible)

"Some are puffed up": φυσιόω (physioō, "to inflate, to puff up"), swelling like a balloon. Some assume Paul does not dare come, so they grow even more brazen. Paul says: I am coming, and when I arrive, what I will look at is not how beautifully you talk (λόγος, "word") but whether you have any real spiritual power (δύναμις, dynamis, "power").

4:20 "For God’s Kingdom is not in word, but in power."

1 Corinthians 4:20(World English Bible)

A short, forceful sentence and one of the chapter's key statements. λόγος (logos, "word") versus δύναμις (dynamis, "power"): in Corinth's culture, which prized rhetorical skill, what people valued most was "speaking well." Paul says: God's kingdom is not talked into existence; it is lived into existence. Has your life actually been changed? Does your ministry bear real fruit? That is what God examines.

4:21 "What do you want? Shall I come to you with a rod, or in love and a spirit of gentleness?"

1 Corinthians 4:21(World English Bible)

The chapter ends on a choice: ῥάβδος (rhabdos, "rod, staff of discipline") or πραΰτης (prautēs, "gentleness")? This is a father speaking to wayward children, not a threat but a chance for them to choose repentance themselves. Paul would rather come in gentleness, but if necessary he has the authority to come with the rod of discipline.

Chapter Synthesis and Pastoral Guardrails

Paul is not opposed to respecting spiritual leaders; he is opposed to turning a leader into a banner of identity.

Key Theological Points of the Chapter

1. Overview of Core Theological Points

Theme Key Point Textual Basis
The apostle's identity The apostle is Christ's lowliest servant and a steward of God's mysteries, not a celebrity to be idolized 4:1
The standard of faithfulness A steward's one criterion is faithfulness, not popularity or visible results 4:2
The limits of judgment No one has the right to render an ultimate verdict on another: only the Lord sees motives, and only the last day reveals them 4:3–5
Grace and pride Everything is received grace; there is no room for any boasting 4:7
The cross-shaped life The real shape of following Christ is not success and respectability but blessing others even while suffering 4:8–13
Spiritual fatherhood Paul's relationship with the Corinthians is not tutor-and-student but father-and-children: discipline flows from love 4:14–15
Word and power God's kingdom does not turn on how well one speaks but on how truly one lives and whether there is fruit of a changed life 4:20

Old Testament Citations and New Testament Echoes

1. Overview of Canonical Intertextuality

1 Corinthians Text Citation / Echo Connection
4:1 "stewards of God's mysteries" Matthew 24:45–46 Jesus' parable of the faithful steward: "Who then is the faithful and wise servant?" Paul lives straight into Jesus' parable
4:5 "bring to light the hidden things of darkness" Romans 2:16 "The day when God judges the secrets of people through Jesus Christ": the final judgment weighs not only outward behavior but inner motives
4:8 "you have come to reign" Revelation 20:4–6 Reigning with Christ is an end-time promise — but the time has not yet come. A correction of "over-realized eschatology"
4:12 "when cursed, we bless" Matthew 5:44; Luke 6:28 A direct practice of the Sermon on the Mount: "Love your enemies, pray for those who persecute you"
4:13 "the filth of the world" Lamentations 3:45 "You have made us the offscouring and refuse among the peoples": Lamentations' description of exiled Israel, which Paul applies to the apostles
4:15 "gave you birth through the gospel" Philemon 10 Paul writes in Philemon of "Onesimus, my child, whom I have fathered in my chains": the metaphor of spiritual "parenting" recurs throughout Paul's letters
4:20 "not in word but in power" 1 Thessalonians 1:5 "Our gospel came to you not only in word, but also in power and in the Holy Spirit": the same principle

Rhetoric and Literary Devices

1. Principal Rhetorical and Literary Devices

Device Location Description
Caustic sarcasm 4:8 "You are already full! Already rich! Already reigning!" — three "already" declarations that are mockery, not praise. Paul uses extreme exaggeration to expose the Corinthians' absurdity
Comparative arrangement (synkrisis) 4:9–13 The apostles' situation (last / foolish / weak / despised / hungry / naked / beaten) versus the Corinthians' self-image (reigning / wise / strong / honored): the wider the gap, the deeper the irony cuts
Hardship catalogue (peristasis catalogue) 4:11–13 In classical rhetoric the "adversity catalogue" was a standard device for proving character (Stoic philosophers used it often). Paul Christianizes it: the point is not to display resilient virtue but to display the cross-shaped way of life
Triple rhetorical question (tricolon interrogative) 4:7 Three escalating questions press in step by step, sealing off every escape route for pride: logically there is nowhere to hide
Emotional pivot 4:14 A one-second switch from the sarcasm and suffering of 4:8–13 to "my beloved children": the reader's emotions are pulled both ways, feeling the tension between Paul's severity and his tenderness
Disjunctive close 4:21 "The rod or gentleness?" — handing the initiative back to the reader, making them responsible for the next step. Rhetorically it builds suspense and sets up the concrete discipline of chapter 5

Key Vocabulary Cards

1. Core Vocabulary of the Chapter

Greek Transliteration Rendering Meaning and Usage
ὑπηρέτης hypēretēs servant Literally "bottom-deck oarsman": the lowest row of rowers on a trireme warship, entirely under the captain's command. Paul uses this word to position the apostle: we do not give the orders; we only carry them out
οἰκονόμος oikonomos steward The servant who managed the estate of a wealthy household. He manages not his own property: the master entrusts it, and he distributes it faithfully. The root of the English word "economy"
πιστός pistos faithful 4:2 names it as the steward's only standard. The same word in 4:17 describes Timothy as a "faithful child," a living example of the faithfulness Paul teaches
θέατρον theatron a spectacle 4:9 pictures the apostles as prisoners awaiting death in the arena while others watch. Theatron refers both to the theater building and to the "spectacle" staged in it: the root of the English word "theater"
περικάθαρμα perikatharma filth 4:13; the material used in purification rituals to wipe away contamination: "a rag used once and thrown away." In some ancient cities a living person was offered as a perikatharma to cleanse the whole city (a scapegoat substituting for collective punishment)
παιδαγωγός paidagōgos tutor 4:15; not a "teacher" but the slave/guardian in the ancient world who escorted a child to and from school. He disciplines but does not father: contrasted with "father" (πατήρ)
φυσιόω physioō puffed up Appears three times (4:6, 4:18, 4:19): "to inflate." This verb is a signature word of 1 Corinthians (6 of its 7 New Testament occurrences are in this letter), exposing the Corinthians' core problem: balloon-like self-inflation

Argument Structure Diagram

1. The Chapter's Argument in Progression

The progression of the argument can be grasped through the structural overview given in the introduction:

The chapter has four movements, from positioning to sarcasm to tenderness to warning:

Tracking the Theological Themes

1. The Summary of Block One (1:1–4:21): A Four-Chapter Unified Argument

How do the four chapters form one complete argument?

Chapter Core Thesis Function
1 The message of the cross overturns human wisdom Tear down the idol: worldly wisdom cannot be trusted
2 God's wisdom is received only through the Spirit Lay the foundation: the one path to knowing God
3 Preachers are only servants; the church belongs to God Redefine: the proper relationship between you and your preachers
4 The apostles' true portrait = suffering stewards Living proof: this is what following the cross looks like

The argumentative strategy: chapter 1 presents the "logic" (the logic of the cross), chapter 2 the "epistemology" (how truth is known), chapter 3 the "ecclesiology" (the preacher's role), and chapter 4 the "praxis" (what it looks like lived out). From abstract to concrete, from head to life.

2. The Boundary between "Judging" and "Discipline"

In 4:3–5 Paul says "do not judge," but in 5:3–5 he is about to "judge" the man committing sexual immorality. Is this a contradiction? No. What 4:3–5 forbids is judging a person's ultimate motives ("what is he really thinking deep down": only God knows that); what chapter 5 requires is dealing with overt sin ("his behavior is public transgression": this the church has the authority to judge).

The distinction:

3. "Imitate Me" (4:16): Paul's Discipleship Strategy

Paul's "imitate me" sounds bold to us today, but in first-century rabbinic culture it was standard practice: disciples learned by imitating their master. Paul clarifies it further elsewhere: "Be imitators of me, just as I am of Christ" (1 Corinthians 11:1). The ultimate object of imitation is not Paul but Christ; yet Paul is the concrete, visible intermediate step on the way to Christ.

This has implications for discipleship in churches everywhere: do we have the courage to say to those we shepherd, "Watch how I live"? If we do not dare say it, the problem is not with the model but with the fact that our lives are not yet enough like Christ's.

Historical Background

1. Paul's "Hardship Catalogues" Compared: 1 Corinthians 4 versus 2 Corinthians 11

Paul lists his sufferings in several letters, forming a distinctive rhetorical pattern of "apostolic credentials":

1 Corinthians 4:11–13 2 Corinthians 11:23–28
Hunger and thirst Often without food
Naked Naked and exposed
Beaten Beaten by the Jews five times with forty lashes less one; beaten with rods three times
No fixed dwelling Frequently on long journeys
Working with our own hands (Explained further in 1 Corinthians 9:6)
Cursed, we bless Anxious care for all the churches
Treated as filth and refuse Let down the Damascus wall to escape

The list in 1 Corinthians 4 is relatively brief and ironic in tone; its purpose is to contrast the Corinthians' self-satisfaction. The list in 2 Corinthians 11 is longer and more specific, because by then Paul needs to defend his apostleship directly. Both lists convey the same message: the mark of a true apostle is not glory but suffering.

Difficult Questions

1. What Does "Not Beyond What Is Written" (4:6) Actually Mean?

"Not to think beyond the things which are written" in 4:6 (the original phrase) is one of the most difficult expressions in 1 Corinthians. What does γέγραπται (gegraptai, "what is written") refer to? Scholars hold three main views:

  1. It refers to the Old Testament passages Paul cited earlier (1:19, 1:31, 2:9, 3:19–20): do not add a halo to a preacher beyond the position the Old Testament assigns
  2. It refers to a slogan current among the Corinthians, perhaps a saying of the time whose content we can no longer fully determine
  3. It refers to the teaching principle of Scripture as a whole: do not go beyond the limits Scripture sets for the human role

Whichever view is right, Paul's emphasis is the same: your exaltation of preachers has "gone too far," beyond what Scripture allows. Any elevation of a person, once it exceeds Scripture's position for that person (servant, steward, fellow worker), becomes idolatry.

This is especially meaningful for church cultures that lean toward "spiritual authority." When some churches equate a pastor's word with God's word, and submission to the pastor with submission to God, that is "beyond what is written." Paul says: no. A preacher deserves to be respected only as a steward and servant, not to be worshiped as God's spokesman.