Still Partners After the Conflict · Small Groups

Love One Another: Life Together in the Body of Christ, Lesson 6. Read Phil 4:1-3. Staying silent face-to-face while forming alliances behind the scenes, or letting one hurt become a permanent exit.

Main passage: Phil 4:1-3

In his letter to the whole church at Philippi, Paul urges two co-workers: "I urge Euodia and Syntyche to think the same way in the Lord." He also asks one co-worker to help them, and in the same sentence he mentions their labor in the gospel. As for Paul and Barnabas themselves, Scripture records truthfully that "they parted ways."

Introduction

There are two common ways a conflict between co-workers ends. One is where people don't speak directly, but form alliances behind the scenes, each finding others to confide in, gradually dividing a team in half—on the surface still serving together, but in reality no longer speaking. Another is where one hurt means permanent withdrawal: stop serving, take on nothing else, stop explaining anything. Philippians 4, at the very beginning, offers just three short verses, yet they give us several very practical directions. Paul opens this way:

Therefore, my brothers, whom I love and long for, my joy and crown, so stand firm in the Lord, my beloved. (Phil. 4:1)

He first addresses the whole church with deep affection: "whom I love and long for," "my joy and crown," only then does he urge these two co-workers. Pastoral warmth and facing difficulty are woven together here. Then he speaks directly:

I urge Euodia and I urge Syntyche to think the same way in the Lord. (Phil. 4:2)

This letter was most likely meant to be read aloud in the church at Philippi—two names, written right there in the letter. This cannot directly serve as grounds for publicly naming anyone in a conflict today: the scope of addressing an issue needs to match the scope of its impact. First verify the facts, and protect those involved. Scripture doesn't explain the cause of their disagreement, how serious it was, or who was responsible. Paul here doesn't issue a judgment; he simply urges each of them separately to "think the same way in the Lord." The basis of that unity is first in the Lord—this doesn't mean facts don't need to be clarified or responsibilities don't need to be accepted; real reconciliation sometimes requires getting the things that need to be said into the open, acknowledging what needs to be acknowledged, and granting the forgiveness that needs to be granted. The next verse is often overlooked, yet very practical:

Yes, I ask you also, true yokefellow, help these women, for they labored with me in the gospel, with Clement also, and the rest of my fellow workers, whose names are in the book of life. (Phil. 4:3)

Paul asked a third person to help. We don't know who this "true yokefellow" is; his task is to help them think the same way again, but Scripture doesn't say exactly how he should help—that help might include listening, clarifying facts, or it might include exhortation. Notice also how Paul introduces these two sisters in the same sentence: "they labored with me in the gospel." When handling conflict, he states their accomplishment—one conflict hasn't erased what they did before. He reaches further still: their names and the names of the rest are in the book of life. Their shared gospel identity doesn't minimize the disagreement, but it reminds them: first and foremost, you are co-workers who have received the same grace, so you have all the more reason to seek earnestly together in the Lord for unity.

Acts 15 records the most candid conflict between co-workers in Scripture:

Barnabas wanted to take John, who was called Mark, with them. But Paul didn't think it wise to take him, because he had deserted them in Pamphylia, and didn't go with them to the work. (Acts 15:37–38)

Scripture writes down both sides' decisions and reasons: Barnabas intended to take Mark, but Paul, because Mark had left them in Pamphylia and not gone with them to the work, thought it unwise to take him. It doesn't explain further the motives behind each person's heart, and it doesn't frame this as a matter of good versus evil.

Then the contention grew so sharp that they departed from each other. Barnabas took Mark with him and sailed away to Cyprus, but Paul chose Silas and departed, being committed by the brothers to the grace of God. He went through Syria and Cilicia, strengthening the churches. (Acts 15:39–41)

Luke doesn't try to smooth things over for them, and he doesn't issue a judgment—the two co-workers simply parted ways. Yet both kept on serving: one team became two, and the work didn't stop. Later events are worth knowing too: Paul mentions Mark in his letters as a co-worker, and in his later years he specifically instructs Timothy to bring him, saying he is "useful to me for service" (2 Tim. 4:11); in 1 Corinthians he speaks positively of Barnabas and puts him on equal footing with himself. As for how Paul and Barnabas got along afterward, Scripture doesn't say.

So this lesson is about practicing how to face difficulty in love: talk face-to-face, not by forming alliances behind the scenes; seek together in the Lord what is true, repentance, forgiveness, and unity—not get tangled up trying to win an argument over who's right, and don't sidestep facts that need to be cleared up or responsibility that needs to be borne; if needed, ask a suitable person to help—the point is to help both sides get to where they can talk again, not to get someone to take your side. Someone who only agrees with everything you say isn't help; they just pour fuel on the fire. And speak of what the other person has done well. If you really can't reach agreement, each going on to serve is also a path forward—just don't treat the other person as an enemy.

Two final things need to be clear. This lesson talks about disagreement between co-workers; sin and injury are different matters. If it involves oppression, financial wrongs, sexual harm, or harm to a minor, it can't be handled with "unity"—protect the person who was harmed first, report it to those who can handle it and to the appropriate institutions, and if necessary contact local public security or police. Don't hand the matter back to the chain of authority involved. Also, some people need to step away for a time. A person deeply wounded needing to rest isn't unspiritual. Don't push them back into serving.

Study notes

1. Paul first addresses the whole church with deep affection, only then urges these two co-workers. Pastoral warmth and facing difficulty can exist at the same time.

2. He names them—this letter would likely be read aloud in the church. This is not a direct basis for publicly naming anyone in a conflict today; the scope of addressing an issue needs to match its impact, and you must first verify facts and protect those involved.

3. Scripture doesn't explain the cause of their disagreement, how serious it was, or who was responsible. Paul doesn't issue a judgment here, but rather urges each of them separately.

4. "Think the same way in the Lord"—the basis of unity is in the Lord. This doesn't mean facts don't need to be clarified or responsibilities don't need to be accepted.

5. He asked a third person to "help" them. Scripture doesn't say exactly how—it could include listening, clarifying facts, or it could include exhortation.

6. He states their accomplishment in the same sentence. One conflict doesn't erase what a person did before.

7. "Their names are in the book of life." Their shared gospel identity doesn't minimize the disagreement, but reminds them they are first of all co-workers who have received the same grace.

8. Acts 15 records both sides' decisions and reasons. Barnabas intended to take Mark; Paul, because Mark had left them in Pamphylia, thought it unwise; Scripture doesn't explain further their deeper motives.

9. "So they parted ways"—Scripture doesn't smooth it over or say who was right.

10. Both kept on serving; one team became two, and the work didn't stop.

11. Paul later said Mark was "useful to me for service." He also speaks positively of Barnabas; as for how the two got along afterward, Scripture doesn't say.

Discussion

Opening (about 10 minutes)

One sentence to open with (leader reads)

What we share in the group stays in the group. There is an exception: if there is ongoing harm, a risk to a child or vulnerable person, or immediate danger of self-harm or harm to others, the leader cannot promise complete confidentiality. Normally, the leader will first try to discuss this with the person and share only necessary information with those who can actually help. If a child or someone unable to protect themselves is involved, or there is immediate danger, do not wait for consent. Contact a pastor, qualified professionals, local police, emergency services or medical services as appropriate. In immediate danger, get help straight away and do not leave the person alone.

Warm-up: When you're doing something together, what kinds of things most easily cause disagreement? (Just the kinds, not the people or the specific incidents; friends joining for the first time can share too)

Leader note: Ask lightly. Usually it's: who decides, what standard should we have, should we do this thing at all. Set the rule here: we're not talking about specific people or incidents today.

Lesson recap (leader reads, about 1 minute, for those who didn't prepare)

This lesson is Philippians 4:1–3. Paul says: Therefore, my brothers, whom I love and long for, my joy and crown, so stand firm in the Lord, my beloved. Then he says: I urge Euodia and I urge Syntyche to think the same way in the Lord. Yes, I ask you also, true yokefellow, help these women, for they labored with me in the gospel, with Clement also, and the rest of my fellow workers, whose names are in the book of life. The parallel passage is Acts 15: Paul and Barnabas were going to visit the churches again. Barnabas wanted to take Mark with them, but Paul thought it unwise because Mark had deserted them in Pamphylia; so they had a sharp disagreement and parted ways. Barnabas took Mark and sailed to Cyprus, Paul chose Silas and went through Syria and Cilicia, strengthening the churches. Today we talk together about: being co-workers even after conflict.

Observation

1. Read verses 1 and 2. What does Paul say before he brings up that matter? What is his urging to those two people? Does he say who is right and who is wrong?

Leader note: He says first, "my brothers, whom I love and long for, my joy and crown." His urging is "to think the same way in the Lord." Not a word of judgment.

2. Read verse 3. Who does Paul ask to do what? How does he introduce those two people? What does he say at the end?

Leader note: He asks the "true yokefellow" to help these two women. He introduces them saying "they labored with me in the gospel." At the end: their names are in the book of life.

3. Read Acts 15:37–41. Why did Paul and Barnabas disagree? What was the outcome? What did each do afterward?

Leader note: Over whether to take Mark with them. The outcome was they had a sharp disagreement and parted ways. Afterward Barnabas took Mark to Cyprus, Paul took Silas and went through Syria and Cilicia, strengthening the churches. Both kept serving.

Interpretation

4. How would "thinking the same way in the Lord" change the way both people clarify facts, acknowledge responsibility, and work through the relationship?

Leader note: This is the center of the lesson—give it time. The basis of unity is in the Lord: both stand before the Lord, so they don't have to fight to win an argument, and they don't have to avoid the facts either. You could ask: if the only goal were to prove who's right, how would this end? If you didn't talk about facts at all, what would happen?

5. How can a third party help both sides get to where they can talk again? When might they also need to help clarify facts or point out responsibility?

Leader note: They can listen with both, help both sides say what they need to say clearly, remind everyone to stand before the Lord; if facts aren't clear or there's obvious wrong, they also need to help clarify and point out responsibility. The leader should make this clear: asking a third party is not taking sides. Someone who only agrees with everything you say isn't help—they just pour fuel on the fire.

6. (Flexible question—talk about it if there's time) Paul and Barnabas "parted ways," and Scripture doesn't say who was right. What do you think about this?

Leader note: Scripture records both sides' decisions and reasons: Barnabas intended to take Mark, Paul thought it unwise because Mark had deserted them in Pamphylia; it doesn't explain their deeper motives and doesn't try to smooth it over. Two things to add: first, both kept serving, the work didn't stop; second, Paul later said Mark was "useful to me for service." As for how Paul and Barnabas got along afterward, Scripture doesn't say—don't supply an ending for it.

Application

7. When you run into conflict, what's usually your reaction: staying silent, stepping back, rushing to explain, finding someone to confide in, or being willing to talk face-to-face? (If you'd like, describe one of these; talk about yourself, not others; friends joining for the first time can think about any group)

Leader note: The leader goes first and is honest. All these are very common—don't judge any of them.

8. This week, which one would you be willing to do? (Choose one direction from three: say one thing to someone you have an unresolved issue with / pray for someone you once had conflict with / speak out someone's accomplishment)

Leader note: For the first direction, add one safety condition: if that matter involved harm, or you're not ready yet, don't go; do the second or third direction instead—you're still taking a step forward. Also remind: if the other person involved oppression or harm, don't go find them alone; talk to the pastor or someone who can handle it first. The action list that follows builds on this.

Prayer and practice

Praying Together (about 15 minutes)

Ask one member to read Philippians 4:2–3 slowly, then read Acts 15:39. Everyone is quiet for two minutes. Each person thinks of someone they once had conflict with. Anyone willing can pray a sentence or two. Those who don't want to speak can pray silently—that's just as much prayer; friends joining for the first time can listen quietly, you're not required to pray or take a stand at all. Finally the leader draws it together and intercedes for unity in the group and the church. Prayer requests stay within the group. Do not put sensitive matters in the app or share them in a group chat. For routine follow-up, first obtain the person’s consent, then privately note only the necessary sentence or two. If a child or someone unable to protect themselves is at risk, or there is immediate danger of self-harm or harm to others, do not wait for consent: contact local emergency services, police or appropriate protective services immediately.

You could open with this direction for prayer:

Lord, thank you that you kept Euodia and Syntyche's names in Scripture, and kept the day that Paul and Barnabas parted ways in Scripture—you didn't smooth it over for anyone, and you didn't pretend there were no conflicts among us. Help us face difficulty in love, not fight to win, and not take sides; help us be willing to acknowledge what needs to be acknowledged and forgive what needs to be forgiven, seeking in truth and grace to be one in the Lord. Give us the humility to ask for help. There are those among us who withdrew because of one hurt; heal them, and don't let us push them back. Help us remember the good things we've done for each other, and not let one quarrel erase them all. In Jesus' name, Amen.

This Week's Action List (about 5 minutes)

After prayer, each person picks one thing below to do this week. Just pick one; if you can't decide right away, that's fine too.

You don't need to record it or report back; if you'd like, you can share about it next time we meet. If you didn't do it, bring the thing that got in the way to prayer.

Want to keep talking?

You could choose “Accepting One Another Across Our Differences” (Romans 14; Romans 15:1–7), or “Bear One Another's Burdens — and Carry Your Own Load” (Galatians 6:1–5).

Leader guide